Content Caffeine #32: Top 4 themes in SEO, new AI ranking study, Google query classes & blogging is dead


Content Caffeine

For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs

Hi there,

Welcome back.

You made it.

You made it through the holidays and family gatherings and did your absolute best not to check your inbox, add to your to-do list, or think about your first week back at your desk.

In the meantime, I've kept tabs on the latest news and trends for you.

You might find a surprise or two below!

See you next time,
Nicole

P.S. Scroll to the end and take 3 seconds to check a box in today's poll.


I want to share your:

Big news, latest resource, or outstanding results.
I'd love to support you by featuring you here. It's FREE!

Smash the button
and show me what you've got.

Insights

4 common themes in SEO predictions

SEO experts have been sharing their takes on SEO trends and what's likely to happen in search this year.

I saw some common themes emerge in the articles I've read and in this recent roundup of opinions on Moz.

Here are 4 that stand out:

1. AI reshapes search

First, AI is reshaping search in ways we can't ignore.

Since your audience can now talk to search engines, I believe we'll see growth in long-tail queries.

We also need to think beyond traditional keyword optimization and consider how to design and optimize content so that it appears in AI-generated responses.

This isn't just about ranking – it's about being a trustworthy source that AI systems reference.

(I recently gave some tips on how to get cited in Search GPT which might interest you).

2. Diversify beyond Google

One trend that's growing is the need to diversify beyond Google.

This move isn't new, but, as AI reshapes search, putting all your eggs in the Google basket appears riskier.

Marketers and content creators are expanding their presence across YouTube and podcasts.

Newsletters are gaining popularity as a way to create stronger connections with an owned audience.

It's all about building multiple traffic streams and stronger community connections.

3. The human element

I know I've said this before, but the human element in content is more important than ever.

Here's what's fascinating: as AI gets better at creating content, the value of genuine, human experiences actually increases.

Think about it.

Anyone can spin up an article using AI.

What AI can't do is reproduce your experiences, stories, and opinions.

I'm encouraging my clients to focus on telling their unique stories and sharing case studies and research that highlights their expertise.

4. Video growth

Video is popping up everywhere.

Brands are sharing product launches, how-to videos, user-generated content, funny stories, peeks behind the scenes, and more.

They're not limiting themselves to YouTube either.

Videos are appearing in blog posts, 'about us' and product pages, and newsletters.

The numbers show that video is effective—LinkedIn users are 20x more likely to share video content, and brand awareness increases by 50%.

Our industry moves fast, so what worked six months ago might not work tomorrow.

I suggest regular testing and staying agile with your strategy over the next 12 months.

Remember, the above tactics (mostly) aren't predictions.

They're opportunities for those of us willing to adapt and innovate.

Which of these trends matter to you?

Reply with your thoughts: I'll feature a few of your comments in my next newsletter.

Related Resource

Fight AI search spam

Wired published a thought-provoking piece in response to the surge in AI-generated material online.

They suggest that individuals are seeking authentic human interactions by turning to platforms that emphasize human moderation and genuine engagement.

Check out their 'anti-algorithm' tactics: To Fight AI Search Spam, Prioritize Real Human Voices.


Quoteworthy

Microsoft is using Bing to trick people into thinking they’re on Google.

If you open Bing and search for Google you’ll now see a giant animated picture of people celebrating, along with a message.

In an X post, Google’s Chrome boss, Parisa Tabriz, made her feelings clear about Microsoft's antics:

"Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, but Microsoft spoofing the Google homepage is another tactic in its long history of tricks to confuse users & limit choice."

Tabriz added it was a "new low" for Microsoft.


It's not SEO

Marie Haynes has a theory on what's happening with search right now.

Her recent article begins with an overview of the December 2024 Core and Spam updates, how to tell whether your site was impacted, and what to do if you were affected by the spam update.

It's worth reading.

But, I found this statement intriguing:

I believe that the launch of Gemini 2.0 in December of 2024 ushered in an improved era of Search…We will see more and more that it’s not SEO that makes pages rank, but rather, having pages that people tend to choose and go on to find to be their satisfying answer.

Wait. What?

I believe Marie means that, while traditional SEO practices remain important, they aren't sufficient on their own to achieve higher search rankings.

We see constant reminders that search engine algorithms are placing greater emphasis on user satisfaction and engagement.

It follows that creating content to meet peoples' needs and providing valuable information is an essential part of SEO strategy.

That's how you improve rankings and get clicks.

SEO is not obsolete.

Reminder: combine tech optimization and great content to get the best results.


Ranking in AI Overviews

A large study by ZipTie suggests that traditional search ranking factors may be less relevant for content appearing in AI Overviews.

Notes from their research on 500,000 queries:

  1. On average, 63% of sources cited in AI Overviews do not appear in the top 10 traditional search results
  2. AI Overviews appear on 18% of queries related to publishers
  3. AI Overviews are extremely dependent on the sample of keywords
  4. You can leverage YouTube to increase your chances of getting featured

These are my 2 favorite quotes from the author:

Don’t treat AI Overviews only as a danger… but also as a way to increase the visibility of your brand in Google.
AI Overviews is not only a click game, but also a branding and PR one.
—Tomasz Rudzki, Co-founder at ZipTie

You'll see more of Rudzki's observations and examples in this report.

I hope these insights help. For more tips, follow me here.

This is not an ad...

Did a friend or colleague forward this newsletter to you?

You can get a copy straight to your inbox twice a month.

You know what to do! (Hit the button now).


Information


✶ Google assigns queries into 1 of 8 classes

Here's another example of what Mark Williams-Cook found in the 'Google endpoint exploit.'

His LinkedIn post contains more detail on the classifications.

✶ View a website as a Googlebot

If you're auditing websites for any technical issue, this tutorial will make life way easier.

Alex Harford shows you how to set up a separate browser in your workstation for viewing sites like a Google mobile crawler.

He also clearly outlines what to investigate during a Googlebot audit.

Get the instructions.

✶The value of intent

I stumbled across this—in a place I never go! From the Bing blog: ​The Value of Intent​-Driven SEO in AI-Powered Search Engines.


Inspiration


✶ Blogging is dead (or is it?)


A Redditor on r/SEO recently asked, "Do Need a Blog For Startup in 2025?"

Poor grammar aside, this question sparked an interesting discussion.

Google's John Mueller stated a simple "no" — implying it's not an SEO requirement.

Many people commented that the answer depends on a variety of factors, such as the specific industry, target audience, and business goals.

While blogs (don't we have a better word for this yet?) may not be a "requirement" for SEO, they still offer significant benefits.

The content and resources on your website help you:

  1. Establish credibility and authority within your industry
  2. Build trust and rapport with potential clients
  3. Provide valuable resources and educational content that can drive leads and conversions

Redditor MaxNardit said:

"Blogs provide an opportunity to showcase your expertise and share real, valuable insights... Let’s also not forget that a well-maintained blog isn’t just an SEO play. It’s a long-term investment in customer education, engagement, and even brand storytelling."

I agree.

While a blog may not be a necessity for a startup in 2025, every business needs a well-thought-out content strategy.

Content marketing still matters.

But, you need to create the right content, for the right people, and publish it in the right place.

This means producing content for specific channels and posting it where your audience is already having conversations.

One of the biggest benefits of a well-researched article is that it's ideal for repurposing.

You could turn one great article into:

  • Newsletter content
  • Video scripts
  • Social posts
  • Infographics
  • Lead magnets
  • A course module

The options are only limited by your imagination.

In 2025, I'm still focussed on original, in-depth content as a solid basis for business growth.

And, quality over quantity.

Reply and tell me what you think about blogging in 2025, or click an option below:

I appreciate your feedback!


Keep in touch

12424 Black Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78748
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Caffeine

My team and I have been helping brands reach their SEO traffic and conversion goals through content and links for over 10 years. Recognized by industry leaders and household brands as an authority in both organic content and digital PR.

Read more from Content Caffeine
graphic from semrush showing survey response on site performance in the past 6 months.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. It's been a wild couple of weeks - in business and life! How are you doing? If you've had trouble keeping up with what's happening in SEO, search, and marketing, I've got you covered. As always, I hope you find value in my original insights and tips. Read on... See you next time,Nicole P.S. Want to steal attention from your competitors? Check out today's 'Inspiration' section. P.P.S. I've added back the 'Dates to...

a pie chart showing the percentage of 5 star reviews Google has deleted

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. Have you noticed how much search news there is lately? Today, I've added a quick 'news' section below so you can catch up. I hope you're enjoying your holidays and relaxing on the couch while you read this. See you next time,Nicole P.S. I'll be back on January 9 with your first newsletter of 2025. Happy New Year! Search News Core updates We hardly had time to blink after the November Core Update before Google...

new search database showing list of people and their details

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. 23 days and 13 hours. That's how long it took the promised 2 week November Update to complete. Now, you can dig into your data to find out how you—or your clients—were impacted. I had to get ruthless with my story selection this week. You might have noticed that there's a lot going on in search, SEO, and content. I hope you enjoy what I found. See you next time,Nicole P.S. I'll be back with your last newsletter...