Content Caffeine #30: Rethinking search, top 3 challenges for agency marketers, SEO & Search GPT, huge Google Search study


Content Caffeine

For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs

Hi there,

Welcome back.

23 days and 13 hours.

That's how long it took the promised 2 week November Update to complete.

Now, you can dig into your data to find out how you—or your clients—were impacted.

I had to get ruthless with my story selection this week.

You might have noticed that there's a lot going on in search, SEO, and content.

I hope you enjoy what I found.

See you next time,
Nicole

P.S. I'll be back with your last newsletter for 2024 on Dec 27.
Happy Holidays to you! I hope you enjoy good company, good food, and a healthy dose of relaxation.


Reader Feature

Free Training

Thanks to Jo Furnival from Sitebulb who sent me this [edited]:

"Our 2024 JavaScript SEO Report highlighted the need for improved education and awareness around JavaScript rendering –- and the SEO issues it can cause."

2000+ people registered for our live training.

Now, we've built that content into a free, on-demand course.

The content was produced in collaboration with the Women in Tech SEO community and Gray Dot Co.

Get Your Free Training


Related links

  1. Sitebulb's 2024 JavaScript SEO Report
  2. Special thanks to Aleej AbuAli, founder of Women in Tech SEO, and Tory and Sam from Gray Dot Co for their expertise.

Would you like the chance to feature here? It's easy:

  1. Look below.
  2. Click that big button.
  3. Send me what you've got.

I want to share your:

Big news, latest resource, or outstanding results.
I'd love to support you by featuring you here. It's FREE!

Smash the button
and show me what you've got.

Insights

Rethinking Search

What eventually contributes to Google's decline won't be another search engine.

It will be something that encourages you to use Google search less–or perhaps any 'search engine.'

Last week, I came across a startup that is rethinking search from the ground up.

They're called Exa and they just launched Websets.

Their goal is to transform the messy web we know into a structured database.

Here's my understanding:

  • Websets are not based on keyword searches. Exa converts webpage content into embeddings that capture meaning rather than just matching words or phrases.
  • The company has processed around 1B web pages so far. Google has about 1T pages, but Exa is prioritizing depth of understanding.
  • The most exciting thing about Websets is that it makes extremely complex searches viable.

For example, you could ask for highly-specific lists of people or businesses:

"Find me technical SEOs based in the Bay Area who've worked at startups and also in AI."

After entering a search you might have time to make a coffee, but the results should be worth it. You'll get precise lists containing hundreds or thousands of entries.

If you need proof, check out this oddly specific sample from Exa:

LinkedIn Profiles: Male; finance; Northern European last name; athletic.

It may be slow, but this database-style approach could reshape how we find and organize information on the web.

Imagine how you could use it.

The possibilities are endless.

Exa say they want to "build perfect search."

At Exa, our goal is to build perfect search — i.e. turn the internet into a super powerful database that you can query however you want.
This is a big first step.

That first step is an encouraging beginning.

If you want more info, you can watch the founder as he demos Websets and/or signup to their waitlist.


SEO in the Age of SearchGPT

OpenAI is gradually building a self-contained location to keep users on its platform.

That’s a logical move given that ~40% of their users exit to Google (according to Semrush data):

Since the integration of SearchGPT (for some users), ChatGPT is positioning itself as a search engine.

This move seems to have been well planned.

OpenAI has formed numerous partnerships with media companies, and recent reports suggest they are working on a web browser with ex-Google Chrome developers.

While SearchGPT is not a direct competitor to Google now, it presents new considerations for SEOs.

Let’s quickly review:

Content creation

SearchGPT is designed for conversational interactions, focusing on questions, context, and discussions.

This means we must create content that reads smoothly, answers questions directly, and provides concise information.

For example, incorporating FAQs and focusing on clearly defined terms and definitions will cater to SearchGPT’s conversational nature.

Use a variety of media

SearchGPT can reference and describe different types of media, not just text.

If you add videos, infographics, and interactive elements into your content this will improve its value.

Label your multimedia content

SearchGPT does understand images, but descriptive text is still important.

It makes your content inclusive and accessible to all end users. Don’t ignore this.

Target high-visibility content sources

SearchGPT seems to link out to content creators more than Google. You could think about targeting high-visibility sources used by SearchGPT to increase your brand’s visibility.

Remember: Always meet user intent.

Keep your content up-to-date

SearchGPT (like Google) prioritizes relevant, up-to-date information. Regularly review your content to keep it fresh.

In the end, the future of SEO will likely involve a hybrid approach, balancing optimization for both traditional search engines and emerging AI platforms like SearchGPT.

A proviso

I’m not suggesting you rely on SearchGPT for research.

It continues to make things up, provide wrong answers, cite incorrect sources, and offer inconsistent answers.

Always check your sources before publishing content, and verify that you’re linking to an original article.

If you want facts, go to Wikipedia!


Huge Google Search Study Reveals How Users Behave

A new study by SparkToro and Datos found that just 148 keywords make up 15% of all Google searches.

The data also showed that:

  • 10,000 queries make up nearly 46% of all search activity.
  • 44% of searches are for branded terms.
  • 51% of searches are informational, like weather updates or “how-to” questions.
  • 14.5% are commercial, aiming to find products or services.
  • Only 0.69% of searches are transactional, i.e. when someone is ready to buy.

Does that spell bad news for direct sales?

You can dive into all the details or just check out the key takeaways from Rand’s post.


Additional resource

  1. Listen to what Sam Altman says about Google, ChatGPT, and search in this interview. Start at 1.18.00.
  2. Go Fish Digital observed that for the query "digital PR agency," ChatGPT Search was not listing "Notable Clients" for their company — unlike their competitors.
    They also realized that ChatGPT Search was frequently citing an article on their website. Chris Long explains what they did and how they fixed the problem.

I hope these insights help. For more tips, follow me here.

This is not an ad...

Did a friend or colleague forward this newsletter to you?

You can get a copy straight to your inbox twice a month.

You know what to do! (Hit the button now).


Information

✶ A simple explanation for indexing issues

Google is indexing fewer pages and dumping those that offer low quality content.

So says Daniel Foley Carter in a LinkedIn post:

“What is the point in storing content that will never be served or is highly unlikely to be served? What is the point in storing content if there are 10 million other iterations of the same thing already indexed? …Google doesn't need to index 10,000,000 lemon cake recipes.”

Carter also offers some power tips if you have concerns about indexing.


✶ Generative AI statistics and trends

Semrush rounded up all the latest statistics you could possibly need on the use of Generative AI.
Marketers use GenAI to create content faster, but concerns persist.

✶ No programming knowledge required

Carl Hendy has a useful, free tool that lets you check if something is in Google's Knowledge Graph.

✶ 130+ Tips for Ecommerce SEO

You might want to save this for a snow day.

Freddie Chatt asked SEO experts for their top tips and they delivered.

This monster post details strategies for analytics, product pages, content strategy, CRO and more.

Fortunately, it's divided into categories so you can easily access what interests you.


Inspiration

✶ The Local Marketing Industry Survey: Agency Edition

BrightLocal just released the results of their marketing agency survey.

They questioned almost 400 local agency marketers, including freelancers and consultants, agency owners, and agency employees.

One important question they asked marketers was:

“What challenges do clients come to agencies with?

The top 3 challenges

  1. Revenue not meeting expectations (46%): This was the most common challenge reported by agency marketers.

    Various factors such as ineffective marketing strategies, economic uncertainty, or unrealistic client expectations are all potential contributors to a decline in revenue.
  2. Customers choosing competitors (38%): This highlights the competitive nature of the market.

    Clients may be losing customers to businesses that offer better products, prices, or service.
  3. This one is a shocker! — Customers cannot find the business online (37%).

The irony of that did not escape me.

Agencies are expected to be experts in helping businesses improve their online visibility and reach their target audience.

Had these new clients used an agency before?

If so, this underscores the need for your agency to:

  1. Continuously invest in your expertise and stay ahead of industry trends.
  2. Improve communication and collaboration with clients.
  3. Clearly define expectations and manage client relationships effectively.
  4. Ensure you have the resources and technology necessary to deliver on your promises.

You’ll notice that the top 3 challenges all impact revenue in some way.

If you want to know what to focus on in 2025, make sure you’re offering the right services to address your prospective client’s needs.

Like me, you’ll find several other thought-provoking insights in the report.


Note: I got a mention in the above report. It made me reflect on what's changed (or hasn't) for women in SEO. Would you like to know my thoughts on this?


Keep in touch

12424 Black Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78748
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Caffeine

My team and I have been helping brands reach their SEO traffic and conversion goals through content and links for over 10 years. Recognized by industry leaders and household brands as an authority in both organic content and digital PR.

Read more from Content Caffeine
graphic from semrush showing survey response on site performance in the past 6 months.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. It's been a wild couple of weeks - in business and life! How are you doing? If you've had trouble keeping up with what's happening in SEO, search, and marketing, I've got you covered. As always, I hope you find value in my original insights and tips. Read on... See you next time,Nicole P.S. Want to steal attention from your competitors? Check out today's 'Inspiration' section. P.P.S. I've added back the 'Dates to...

Bar chart with red bars showing how Google classifies queries into 8 types

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. You made it. You made it through the holidays and family gatherings and did your absolute best not to check your inbox, add to your to-do list, or think about your first week back at your desk. In the meantime, I've kept tabs on the latest news and trends for you. You might find a surprise or two below! See you next time,Nicole P.S. Scroll to the end and take 3 seconds to check a box in today's poll. I want to...

a pie chart showing the percentage of 5 star reviews Google has deleted

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. Have you noticed how much search news there is lately? Today, I've added a quick 'news' section below so you can catch up. I hope you're enjoying your holidays and relaxing on the couch while you read this. See you next time,Nicole P.S. I'll be back on January 9 with your first newsletter of 2025. Happy New Year! Search News Core updates We hardly had time to blink after the November Core Update before Google...