Content Caffeine #66: This ONE type of content gives marketers an edge in search


Content Caffeine

For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs

Hi there,

Too few marketers make use of subject-matter experts in their content strategies. Below, I explain why I believe it gives you an edge.

Other highlights:

  • Google's "Expert Advice" update
  • Does brand authority beat topical authority?
  • How well can you influence AI citations?

As always, thanks for being here.

I'll be back on May 28 (have a great Memorial Day weekend!).

Nicole

P.S. Did we miss something in Google's push for non-commodity content?

I want to share your:

Big news, latest resource, or outstanding results.
I'd love to support you by featuring you here. It's FREE!

Smash the button
and show me what you've got.

Insights


Subject-matter Experts: A Marketer's Content Edge


The recent discussions around "expert advice" and "non-commodity" content made me rethink this stat:

Nearly 75% of enterprise marketers say fewer than 15% of their subject-matter experts (SMEs) contribute to thought leadership.
— Content Marketing Institute: B2B Content and Marketing Trends


SMEs as content sources

While the CMI report focused on enterprise teams, you'll find SMEs in most brands and businesses, and the knowledge locked inside their heads is an excellent source of non-commodity content.

I'm not just referring to CEOs, CFOs or CTOs, etc.

Sales leaders, product specialists, and customer support managers all have deep experience, strong opinions, and stories to tell. What they often don't have is the skill or time to sit down and write an article.

That's where you come in.

How to turn internal knowledge into content assets

Keep the process simple because this aids 'buy in' from your clients.

Use this basic workflow:

  • Schedule quarterly interview cycles with experts (record and transcribe)
  • Send questions in advance so the conversation is focused and efficient
  • You're not asking them to write anything (unless they choose to bring notes)
  • Look for patterns, anomalies, and unusual events or stories
  • Pair those insights with surveys, usage trends, customer behavior data or other internal reporting
  • Convert your findings into clear and engaging narratives

I've found that people who would never sit down to write a blog post will happily answer 10 questions over a coffee. And, when you treat SMEs as research partners, they'll willingly share their knowledge, advice, and insights.

Done consistently, this process gives your clients original, data-driven articles that are on brand and can't be copied.

The Digital PR benefit

Original insights travel further.

Journalists, analysts, and industry creators want fresh angles and credible data, so your interview/research stories are far more pitchable than a roundup of third-party data someone scraped off Google.

If AI search results now reward information gain, experience, and expert advice, then these assets are worth the investment for any brand.


The Expert Advice Update


As Google rolls out updates to AI Mode and AI Overviews, I wonder how the new "Expert Advice" section will influence clicks to niche sites and communities?

In their May 6 blog post, Google stated, "AI responses will now include a preview of perspectives from public online discussions, social media, and other firsthand sources."

The “expert advice” layer is not an experiment.

You'll see it in the most visible part of the Search page as Google begins prioritizing “experience” as a ranking signal (E-E-A-T again). This also fits in with their push toward "non-commodity" content.

This could go one of two ways:

1. It will drive additional clicks to content written by people with provable experience in their field. We'll see original insights, ideas, and opinions that an LLM/AI can't replicate.

This would be a plus for publishers, creators, and brands.

2. There's always a chance Google will surface content from people who have zero idea what they're talking about!

If conversations and discussions become core sources of AI answers, then forums and communities might gain more exposure than they already have (looking at you, Reddit).

Will Google get this right or are we about to witness Reddit overload in our search results?

Go vote in my poll on this…please.


Reminder

Google I/O is scheduled for May 19-20. We've had hints about additional AI product updates, but nothing is clear.

Will we finally get meaningful click and traffic data for AI features?

A month ago, Eli Schwartz predicted that AI Mode would launch as the default search experience.

What do you think?


Do you follow me on LinkedIn? I share regular tips and stories I don't have room for here. Come and join me​.

This is not an ad...

Grow your brand mentions and visibility online.

Digital PR is fast becoming the new organic search.

If you need innovative ways to stand out from your competitors, we have ideas for you.

↩ Steer your brand North today.


Information

✶ What influences AI citations?

If you missed Cyrus Shepard's analysis of what influences AI search citations, you might want to bookmark it for reference.

Using real data from 54 experiments, patents, and case studies, he shows how authority, brand mentions, and content structure affect citations inside AI answers.

Spoiler alert: While the evidence suggests that specific practices can boost AI citations, most of the critical factors align with traditional SEO practices.

Check the scores on all 23 ranking factor descriptions.

✶ Refreshing content

Google wants to see meaningful change when you refresh content, not just edited dates and times.

h/t to Mark Williams-Cook for his wonderful illustrations.

✶ Brand authority beats topical authority

Andrew Holland makes the uncomfortable case (for some) that topical authority was co-opted by the SEO industry as a commercial wrapper for content production — an easy-to-sell retainer engine.

Holland argues that large language models and AI search experiences increasingly synthesize responses from trusted brands, which means visibility depends on reputation, expertise signals, and consistent presence across the web.

Brand building, Digital PR, expert authorship, and off-site mentions are the goals.

What do you think?


Inspiration

The Last Quiet Thing


Terry Godier's bio says:

"I design and build software that tries not to waste your time. I write about what happens when technology forgets that’s the job."

What he doesn't say, is that he's also an excellent writer.

I enjoy his perspectives on tech and its use.

I believe you will, too.

It takes 5 minutes to read his article, but after you're done, I guarantee you'll think slightly differently about tech.

Excerpt

Sometime in the last twenty years, our possessions came alive.

Not all at once. Not dramatically. One by one, the objects in our lives opened their eyes, found our faces, and began to need us.
Nothing you own is finished. Everything exists in a state of permanent incompletion, permanently needing. Your phone needs updates, needs charging, needs storage cleared, needs passwords rotated.
Your apps need permissions reviewed, terms accepted, preferences re-configured after every update.
Your subscriptions need evaluating, need renewing, need canceling, need justifying to yourself every month when the charge appears.
The purchase isn't the end of anything. It's the first day of a relationship you didn't agree to, with no clean way out.
You live in a house full of dependents...

That's all for today. Thanks for being here!
I'll see you again on May 28.

In the meantime, feel free to ask me a question, send an interesting link, or tell me what's on your mind. I read all your emails!


Dates to watch

June Monthly Observances

  • LGBTQ Pride Month
  • Caribbean-American Heritage Month
  • Great Outdoors Month
  • Men’s Health Month
  • National Safety Month
  • National Zoo and Aquarium Month

Weekly Observances

  • June 1-7: National Garden Week
  • June 1-7: National Headache Awareness Week
  • June 9-15: National Men’s Health Week
  • June 15-21: National Roller Coaster Week

Days

  • June 1: Global Parents Day
  • June 5: Hot Air Balloon Day
  • June 5: World Environment Day
  • June 6: D-Day
  • June 6: Belmont Stakes
  • June 7: Tony Awards
  • June 8: World Oceans Day
  • June 8: National Best Friends Day
  • June 9: Donald Duck Day
  • June 11: Kamehameha Day
  • June 11-14: Bonnaroo Music Festival
  • June 14: National Flag Day
  • June 15: Trinity Sunday
  • June 18-21: U.S. Open PGA
  • June 19: Juneteenth
  • June 19: Chinese Dragon Boat Festival
  • June 21: Father’s Day
  • June 21: Summer Solstice
  • June 25-26: Ashura
  • June 29-July 12: Wimbledon
  • June 30: International Asteroid Day

Keep in touch

12424 Black Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78748
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Caffeine

My team and I have been helping brands reach their SEO traffic and conversion goals through content and links for over 10 years. Recognized by industry leaders and household brands as an authority in both organic content and digital PR.

Read more from Content Caffeine
a graph showing brand site visits per day after being cited in AI search. 1 line shows existing customers and the other shows new customers. visits of new customers increase ~117% after being cited in ChatGPT

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Did DuckDuckGo pull off the biggest PR coup in its history? I discuss what happened below. I also cover: Misleading data in research from AI tool platforms Why the best articles don't always win in AI search GEO has volatility, just like SEO As always, thanks for being here. I'll be back on July 9.Nicole P.S. I wish you a great weekend of celebration, fun, and togetherness with your family and friends next week. Here's to...

a list of data google must provide to publishers after the CMA decision in the UK

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, In big news, a German Court ruled that Google is liable for false or defamatory claims in its AI Overviews. This decision could have far-reaching implications. See the story below. Today's highlights: What Google must provide in AI Search reporting - and when Is Google Zero a lie? How to translate KPIs into business impact And much more below. As always, thanks for being here. I'll be back on June 25.Nicole P.S. What's your...

X post from DuckDuckGo saying that people are complaining about Google's new AI Search are that DuckDuckGo signups are up 30%

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, My 6 takeaways on the changes to Search might give you something to think about. It's Google, but not as we knew it. Reply and tell me which one you're acting on today. Other highlights: DuckDuckGo surges Preferred sources now in AI search features ChatGPT shows more links As always, thanks for being here. I'll be back on June 11. Nicole P.S. Well, this blew up. What advice do you have for this SEO/Redditor? I want to share...