Content Caffeine #46: 30% rank SEO #1, core update winners and losers, traditional ranks vs AIOs


Content Caffeine

For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs

Hi there,

Google added an AI Mode button on the right side of the search box.

Have you seen it yet?

We may never be able to accurately track traffic from AIOs and AI Mode, but getting your brand (or your clients' brands) mentioned in AI-enabled search is a huge credibility lever.

I discuss the best way to do that in the 'Inspiration' section below.

Today's highlights include:

  • SEO ranks #1 in B2B
  • June Core Update: Winners and Losers
  • Traditional and AI Search Results Overlap

As always, thanks for being here.

I'll be back on August 7.
Nicole

P.S. Sometimes, I get a fun comment on one of my posts. You can leave a comment, too :)


I want to share your:

Big news, latest resource, or outstanding results.
I'd love to support you by featuring you here. It's FREE!

Smash the button
and show me what you've got.

Insights

SEO Still Leads in B2B Marketing Effectiveness


Here's some data that will make you smile:

A recent survey from SurferSEO shows that 30% of marketers rank SEO as their #1 most effective B2B channel.

This is double the effectiveness of any other strategy.

Positions 2 and 3 tell us something, too.

Organic social media (14%) and content marketing (13%) are practically tied, and sit well above everything else.

I see this as validation of the 'SEO-content flywheel.'

Great content isn’t enough if no one can find it

You need that flywheel working for you:

1. SEO drives discovery.

2. Content marketing provides the substance that converts visitors into leads.

3. Organic social amplifies that content to grow awareness.

They're not separate channels competing for budget, but actually three legs of the same stool.

Each leg helps build long-term brand authority.

B2B buying behavior

The data also reinforces what we know about B2B buying behavior.

Paid ads only hit 9%, while organic approaches dominate the top spots.

And influencer marketing? Just 3% said it was their most effective channel.

Those numbers tell us B2B buyers are still more persuaded by expertise and search visibility than by hype.

B2B buyers aren't impulse purchasers.

They research, evaluate, and build trust over time.

That's exactly what great SEO and content strategy delivers.

When 57% of the top-performing channels (SEO + content + organic social) are in our wheelhouse, it's time to think bigger about how these strategies work together.

Organic, value-first approaches still work in B2B.

We just need to make sure we maximize that advantage.

Which option would you have selected for this question?

Thanks for voting.

You'll see the results in my next newsletter.


Quoteworthy

OpenAI is reportedly close to launching its web browser.

Then I thought about what Sam Altman said on the first episode of OpenAI’s new podcast:

People have a very high degree of trust in ChatGPT, which is interesting, because AI hallucinates. It should be the tech that you don't trust that much.
—Sam Altman, CEO, OpenAI

Could Altman convince you that OpenAI's browser is better than the alternatives?

(Note: The web browser is not to be confused with the autonomous ChatGPT Agent which launched last week).


Winners and Losers: June Core Update

Google’s June 2025 core update ended last Thursday and took 16 days and 18 hours to complete.

Everyone I’ve talked to saw a large amount of volatility—with the swings continuing after the update supposedly finished.

Post any core update, there’s always plenty of entertaining discussion and opinions about the effects.

Check these 2 examples:

‘Whitey’ on Webmaster World:

  • Winners: sites with updated, experience-rich, author-backed content and strong UX.
  • Losers: thin affiliate sites, mass AI content, expired-domain spam.

‘Martin Ice Web’ disagreed, saying, “… you see things very different to me.”

  • Winners: sites with very thin content : one low res picture + h1
  • Losers: well established sites, experience-rich, author-backed content and strong UX.

He added, “…compelling sites have been replaced by low content sites. google is not able to distinguish between AI and human written content. Therefore all content based sites have been devalued.”

I disagree with 90% of Martin Ice Web's thoughts, but let's move on...

Partial recoveries

Early on in the update, there were signs that some sites affected by previous core updates and helpful content updates were experiencing partial recoveries.

Glenn Gabe provided screenshots of those sites’ surges here and here.

But, these examples are rare.

Actions to take after a core update

My advice remains the same:

  1. Keep calm: Resist the urge to overhaul your site straight away. Shifts are normal post updates, so wait a week or two and let the dust settle.
  2. Review the data: Look at changes in clicks, impressions, and average position after July 17. Combine that with traffic data to spot trends, not just isolated dips.
  3. Audit content: After a month, update outdated material, remove fluff, and improve pages that lack depth or originality.
  4. Address the tech: Review mobile performance optimization, resolve any broken links or redirect issues, and add structured data markup.

What stories can you share from this latest update?

Hit reply with your examples, and I’ll feature some in my next letter.


Related: Barry Schwartz aggregated data from Sistrix, Similarweb, Semrush and others in his post-update overview.


Traditional and AI Search Results Overlap

When it comes to visibility in AIO responses (top 3 links), traditional search presence appears to play a significant part.

Key data from Ahrefs’ study:

  • 76.10% of AI Overview-cited pages rank in the top 10
  • 9.50% of AI Overview-cited pages rank between position 11-100
  • 14.40% of pages cited in AI Overviews do not rank in the SERPs (i.e. rank below position 100)

Extra: Ahrefs’ notes on the fan-out query theory might interest you.


Related: Josh Blyskal from Profound analyzed 19 million citations from Google AI Mode.

He summarized his findings in a LinkedIn post saying, “every page with your name on it is now in the running to influence the answer. AI Mode is looking everywhere.


Do you follow me on LinkedIn? I share regular tips and stories I don't have room for here. Come and join me​.

This is not an ad...

Grow your brand mentions and visibility online.

Digital PR is fast becoming the new organic search.

If you need innovative ways to stand out from your competitors, we have ideas for you.

↩ Steer your brand North today.


Information

✶ Showing up in ChatGPT answers

A tip from Dan Hinckley:

ChatGPT-User bot that accesses your website as part of a conversation is only pulling your HTML. No JavaScript. No CSS. No images.

It just wants your Text.

If your key content only appears after JS renders, or if your metadata is injected dynamically, ChatGPT probably isn’t seeing it. Same goes for pages that rely heavily on layout or visual storytelling.

So if you want your content to show up in ChatGPT answers, make sure your HTML has all the important text right there in the source.

His post covers all the details you want to know.

✶ Not so fast

We ran a randomized controlled trial to see how much AI coding tools speed up experienced open-source developers.
The results surprised us: Developers thought they were 20% faster with AI tools, but they were actually 19% slower when they had access to AI than when they didn't.
Metr on Bluesky


We have anecdotal evidence on the time-saving benefits of content and SEO tools, but no hard evidence.

Who's going to run a trial similar for these tools?

(Please let me know if you're aware of any trial results).


Inspiration

PR's Natural Advantage in AI Search

There's a key point content experts keep missing about AI search engines: They don't just pull from top-ranking content.

Instead, they prioritize sources they view as credible, clear, and relevant to each specific query.

This aligns perfectly with PR.

Digital PR is already great at communicating the credibility AI looks for (or it should be).

Every press release, research report, or thought leadership piece is designed to establish trust, communicate clearly, and position your clients as influential voices.

But, your content is only one piece of a bigger picture.

Who's talking about you?

AI search engines look at who's talking about you, where you're mentioned, and how you're described across the web.

The brands winning in AI search don't necessarily have the most (or even the best) content.

What they have is the right kind of mentions in the right places.

I'm talking about high-authority sites, industry publications, review roundups, and dominant blogs.

You must build the third-party credibility that LLMs appear to rely on.

AI will connect the dots and incorporate what trusted sources say about you from your bylines, quotes, interviews, and more.

AI-enabled search isn't changing every rule of the game, but it makes PR's natural advantages impossible to ignore.

The bottom line: Don't put off investing in Digital PR. The impact of PR-boosted brand mentions now carries extra weight.

P.S. If you don't have a PR resource with the right contacts, then potential brand mentions will remain out of your reach.

Hit reply and ask how I can help.


I'll see you again on August 7.

In the meantime, feel free to ask me a question, send an interesting link, or tell me what's on your mind. I read all your emails!


Dates to watch

August Monthly Observances

  • Back to School Month
  • National Breastfeeding Month
  • Family Fun Month
  • National Peach Month
  • National Eye Exam Month

Weekly Observances

  • August 1-7: International Clown Week
  • August 3-9: National Farmers’ Market Week
  • August 25-31: Be Kind to Humankind Week

Days

  • August 1: National Girlfriends Day
  • August 1: International Beer Day
  • August 2: NFL Hall of Fame Game & Pre-season
  • August 3: National Friendship Day
  • August 5: National Oyster Day
  • August 7: Purple Heart Day
  • August 7: National Lighthouse Day
  • August 8: International Cat Day
  • August 9: Book Lover’s Day
  • August 9: Raksha Bandhan
  • August 10: National S'mores Day
  • August 11: Victory Day
  • August 13: Left Handers Day
  • August 13: Filet Mignon Day
  • August 16: National Honey Bee Day
  • August 19: World Humanitarian Day
  • August 19: World Photography Day
  • August 20: National Radio Day
  • August 21: Senior Citizens Day
  • August 26: Women’s Equality Day
  • August 26: National Dog Day
  • August 30: Frankenstein Day
  • August 30: National Beach Day

Keep in touch

12424 Black Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78748
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Caffeine

My team and I have been helping brands reach their SEO traffic and conversion goals through content and links for over 10 years. Recognized by industry leaders and household brands as an authority in both organic content and digital PR.

Read more from Content Caffeine
A pie chart showing how AIOs currently rank. Most are still in position 1 at 87.6%, but 10.4% are now in position 2 or 3.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there,Today's highlights include: The correlation between AIO clicks and income How individuals use generative AI in 2025 - AKA, "Connect with a human today." Are you mixing too many search intents in your content? As always, thanks for being here. I'll be back on July 24.Nicole P.S. Do you ever forward this newsletter to a friend or colleague? Reply with a "Yes" if you do (because I'm working on something for you). P.P.S. I'm sorry...

bar chart showing the most cited domains in AI Overviews. Quora and Reddit are at the top.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs View in browser Hi there, It's not all about AI :) Today's highlights include: The Redditification of Search Results [Insights] What Metric Matters Most for SEO? [Insights] Statista's Content Marketing Trend Study 2025 [Information] Polished Content, Empty Thinking [Inspiration] Thanks for being here and have a wonderful July 4th weekend! I'll be back on July 10.Nicole P.S. I recently posted a quick reality check for your SEO strategy....

Bar chart showing percentage of people who used traditional search vs AI tools for search.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Did you see this?Anthropic (Claude) started an AI-generated blog and it only lasted a month. Maybe, just maybe, the content wasn't up to the standard of an expert, human writer? The highlights today include: How traditional rankings drive AI Search Let's put search data into perspective What's the top driver for showing up in AIOs? You have a passive page problem (scroll to the Inspiration section) Thanks for being here and...