Content Caffeine #26: Google ads threat, B2B research wins SEO, Meta madness, and new AI SEO report


Content Caffeine

For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs

Hi there,

Welcome back.

BIG NEWS: Semrush acquires Search Engine Land. Here's what Charles Floate thinks about it.

Today, you'll see my thoughts on:

  • The data-backed value of B2B research
  • Google's ad dominance under threat
  • Meta's madness

And more.

Enjoy the end of your week and I'll see you next time,
Nicole

P.S. AMA: What burning questions do you have about Digital PR, SEO or content marketing? Reply with your questions and I'll answer them soon.


I want to share your:

Big news, latest resource, or outstanding results.
I'd love to support you by featuring you here. It's FREE!

Smash the button
and show me what you've got.

Insights

The Value of Original Research in B2B

I’m a big advocate of original research in B2B marketing.

That’s because it’s one of the key strategies we’ve used to help our clients grow their organic traffic and get cited in major media publications.

So, I was curious about Stratabeat’s analysis of what’s currently working in SEO for B2B SaaS companies.

They took data from 300 websites and measured their performance from April 2023 to April 2024.

While the report covers activities like audience segmentation, blogging frequency, and online tools, it’s the compelling statistics about original research that got my attention.

Key findings from Stratabeat’s study

1. Increased Google Top 10 Rankings

Websites that conducted original research saw an average increase of 50% in Google Top 10 organic ranking keywords.

In contrast, sites without original research experienced a decline of 8.1%.

2. Organic Traffic Growth

The study found that websites offering original research increased their organic traffic by an average of 41.2%, compared to just 14.9% for those without it.

This means that websites with original research enjoyed ~2.8 times the organic traffic growth rate compared to their counterparts.

3. Referring Domain Growth

Original research attracts backlinks like no other content! Among websites conducting original research, 95.1% saw an increase in referring domains.

The average increase in referring domains for these sites was 27.1%.

The numbers above are impressive.

But, they don’t tell you the whole story.

In my experience, the benefits of producing original research extend beyond SEO.

Let me show you what I mean…

How the benefits of original research extend beyond SEO

We all want to jump to the top of the SERPs and drive organic traffic.

Those are significant advantages, but the value of original research is much broader.

Here’s what I’ve found:

Establish authority and credibility

a) Primary source of information

When a B2B company publishes original research, it often becomes the primary source for unique data.

This status drives more backlinks from other websites, as media outlets and industry peers cite the research in their own content.

You effectively establish your company (or your client’s) as an authoritative source in your industry. (E.E.A.T).

b) Control over the narrative

Once you’re a key source of valuable data and information, you have the power to shape discussions around industry trends and challenges.

This control allows you to present your findings in a way that aligns with your brand’s vision and messaging.

c) Building trust

High-quality, data-driven content fosters trust among potential clients.

We know that B2B buyers seek reliable information to inform their purchasing decisions.

So, when you provide factual insights that help your audience make those decisions, you raise your brand’s credibility.

d) Lead generation

Research reports can serve as gated or ungated assets that generate leads.

Every time a reader gives you their contact information for access, you’re growing a list of potential clients to market to.

Fuel your media relations and Digital PR efforts

a) Ongoing coverage opportunities

Research reports often have a longer shelf life than typical press releases.

Journalists may return to the data for follow-up articles or discussions long after the initial publication. This helps keep your brand in the spotlight.

b) Social shares and engagement

Statistics and findings from original studies capture attention on social media platforms, where users are eager to share knowledge with their connections.

This organic sharing amplifies your reach and increases brand visibility.

Improve engagement

a) Building relationships

Publishing research also provides more opportunities to connect with industry experts, stakeholders, and potential clients.

These connections often lead to collaborations, partnerships, or simply increased awareness of your brand.

I've seen this work in my business. I've spoken about Digital PR on popular podcasts like Buzzstream, and discussed research, women in SEO and more with experts at Search Engine Land.

Drive business growth

a) Informed decision-making

B2B buyers rate research reports as one of the most valuable types of content during evaluations. Your research can positively influence their decisions.

b) Long-term ROI

Your investment in research will yield long-term returns through increased brand loyalty, higher conversion rates, and improved customer retention.

I've seen the ongoing benefits compound over time for my clients.

Have you published any original research?

Reply with a link to your article or PDF and I'll share the best content in our next newsletter.


Is Google Losing Its Grip on Search Advertising?

A recent Wall Street Journal (WSJ) article set off alarm bells by stating that Google’s search advertising dominance is under threat.

The article attributed this decline to three main factors:

  • The rise of TikTok: Attributed to capturing user attention and ad dollars.
  • Growth of AI search engines like Perplexity: Seen as providing a viable alternative to traditional search.
  • Antitrust pressure: Suggesting Google’s monopoly might be weakening.

A closer examination of the data by Rand Fishkin from SparkToro reveals a different picture.

He urges caution against misinterpreting the situation.

I've dropped the key points from his analysis below.

[N.B. The quotes in green are from his article— which is actually a video transcript. Readability is lacking in places].

1. Market Share Stability

Rand asserts that Google maintains a strong market share, approximately 88% in the U.S. and over 90% globally.

On average, users are searching Google two hundred times per month which is up from last year. So that suggests Google search advertising business should be stronger not weaker.

2. Misleading Growth Claims

The Wall Street Journal attributes potential market share losses to the rise of platforms like TikTok and AI search engines.

Fishkin argues that while these platforms are growing, they currently have minimal impact on Google’s search advertising revenue.

But if TikTok is this threat that the Wall Street Journal is making it out to be, why aren’t they calling out DuckDuckGo. It’s way up here.

3. Data Interpretation

The WSJ highlights that Google’s share of the U.S. digital ad market is projected to decrease, with estimates suggesting it could fall below 50% in 2025, primarily due to growing competition.

It didn’t it barely mentioned Amazon, here’s where search advertising, search advertising spend is going. Google is growing more dollar wise, it’s just that Amazon’s growing faster as a percent because they were a smaller percent before.

4. User Behavior Insights

Rand states that a significant majority (83%) of users still rely solely on traditional search engines, with 99% of those using AI tools also continuing to use Google frequently.

5. Emerging Competitors

He identifies other companies like Walmart and Instacart as significant players in the digital advertising space, suggesting that their growth is contributing to shifts in the market rather than a direct threat from TikTok or AI search engines.

I don’t believe we’re missing any relevant information here.

Do you see any flaws in his assessment, or have any first-hand knowledge of what’s happening in the ad industry?

Let me know if you have data to share.

I hope these insights help. For more tips, follow me here.

This is not an ad...

Did a friend or colleague forward this newsletter to you?

You can get a copy straight to your inbox twice a month.

You know what to do! (Hit the button now).


Information

✶ AI SEO Benchmark Report 2024: Key Stats & Insights

We discovered several surprising statistics in this report.

3 examples:

  • Despite the rise of AI, a surprising 72% of professionals haven’t adopted AI tools in their SEO strategies.
  • AI is automating 44.1% of key SEO tasks, including content creation and keyword research, boosting efficiency for users.
  • 29.9% of AI users believe that AI-generated content performs better than human-written content in rankings and engagement.

I’m wondering which “pioneering marketers” they surveyed.

What do you think of these numbers?

✶ B2B Content Marketing Benchmarks, Budgets, and Trends: Outlook for 2025 [Research]

Speaking of original research…

You have sooo little competition.

If only 36% of B2B marketers are publishing original research, the door is wide open for you to attract some attention!


Inspiration

✶ Meta prioritizes novelty over practicality

Who needs celebrity voices, AI-generated fake events, and phony photos of llamas in pajamas? (I made the last one up).

Meta is attracting criticism over its push to create AI content that has zero value.

The main purpose of social media has always been to connect people, share real experiences and information, and build relationships online.

Meta seems out of touch with its users.

They've already canned AI chatbots and other initiatives that had no appeal for their audience.

The deeper issue is that we're eroding trust and relatability in social media.

When you opt for artificial representations, you diminish real personal experiences.

You create a culture where people prioritize online validation over authentic interaction with their surroundings, e.g., those fake Northern Lights photos.

Engaging with fake stories distorts perceptions of reality, leading individuals to form beliefs based on inaccuracies rather than facts.

This perpetuates misinformation cycles, making it increasingly challenging for users to discern truth from falsehood.

It's our joint responsibility to bridge divides, promote understanding, and encourage active participation in both our local and global communities.

Social media can—and should be—a powerful tool for connection, learning, positive social change, and personal growth.

Let's keep it real!


Keep in touch

12424 Black Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78748
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Caffeine

My team and I have been helping brands reach their SEO traffic and conversion goals through content and links for over 10 years. Recognized by industry leaders and household brands as an authority in both organic content and digital PR.

Read more from Content Caffeine
image showing the second-order effects of AI. there are 5 colored rungs, like a ladder. the first rung says 'gen ai generates content' and the last rung is labelled 'trusted authentic content becomes more important than ever'

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, May 1 is a public holiday just about everywhere, except North America. If no one replies to your messages today, you know why. In other news... My content feed is overrun by AI-related themes. On the bright side, I found an interesting AI framework to get feedback on my writing. You'll find that in the "Quote-worthy" section below. Thanks for being here and I'll see you next time,Nicole P.S. I love supporting my readers, i.e....

a horizontal bar graph with text on the left and a purple bar showing percentages. responses to a question on which types of pages people prioritize when link building. Articles, homepages and product pages were the top 3.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Here's what I've got for you today: Passage ranking back in focus [Insights] A new link-building trends report [Information] What Google is testing [Insights] The thing killing your creative marketing [Inspiration] Enjoy! Thanks for being here and I'll see you next time,Nicole P.S. After a break from social media, I'm back on LinkedIn. You'll find useful tips and content I don't have space for in this letter. If we're not...

A comparison of Kagi search showing user centric search benefits in green on the left hand side, and ad-based search on the right hand side. the left side has a green background, the right side has the text in red.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, You'll see a bunch of news and updates below, but they'll take less time to read.Is that better for you? Here's how you voted on this question in my last newsletter: "Which of these B2B marketing strategies will you focus on in 2025." Community: 66.7% Audio content: 0% Neither: 33.3% Thanks for being here and I'll see you next time,Nicole P.S. Is a lack of brand visibility holding you back? I've helped brands achieve a 400%...