Content Caffeine #33: SEO performance up, Google's real motive, Zero click rises, AI & search


Content Caffeine

For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs

Hi there,

Welcome back.

It's been a wild couple of weeks - in business and life!

How are you doing?

If you've had trouble keeping up with what's happening in SEO, search, and marketing, I've got you covered.

As always, I hope you find value in my original insights and tips. Read on...

See you next time,
Nicole

P.S. Want to steal attention from your competitors? Check out today's 'Inspiration' section.

P.P.S. I've added back the 'Dates to Watch' below.


Blogging is alive and well

The response was small, but as SEOs and marketers, we know that well-written content provides long-term value.

I want to share your:

Big news, latest resource, or outstanding results.
I'd love to support you by featuring you here. It's FREE!

Smash the button
and show me what you've got.

Insights

The rise of zero-click in search

Zero-click search, zero-click content, and zero-click marketing.

ln the past 2 weeks, I've seen more chat about 'zero-click' online.

I recall it was Rand Fishkin who coined the term 'zero-click search' back in 2021.

Zero-click content and zero-click marketing followed.

In 2024, an estimated 58.5% of Google searches ended without a click.

Since mid last year, featured snippets and AI overviews may have increased that number slightly.

It's noticeable that zero-click answers and AI overviews dominate a number of big search categories.

This means if the audience you're trying to attract uses generic and informational queries, you must find alternative ways for people to find your brand.

A two-pronged approach to search

On one hand, we need to shift our focus from solely driving clicks to delivering immediate value that shows within search results.

On the other hand, we need to look at where our target audience is likely to discover our brand (and our clients' brands).

SEOs and marketers are experimenting more with social media, industry news sites, and video for brand awareness and content distribution.

Why are they doing this?

I believe that while traditional search has always been a great foundation, it is turning into a reward for other successful marketing activities.

You can use short-form, high-value content to answer questions on social media, provide expert insights for industry publications, and feature in newsletters or YouTube Shorts.

The point of zero-click marketing is to answer people's questions and get visibility within the search results.
Your brand may not always get direct traffic, but you'll be seen as a useful source of information, which improves brand recognition and trust.

The point is, we must continue to experiment with and diversify our SEO and marketing tactics.

A strong brand presence will naturally improve your search performance.

Is zero-click affecting your SEO strategy?

Hit reply and tell me what you're doing.


AI overviews in search...again

Last week's 'Moz Whiteboard Friday' by Tom Capper included this graph:

About 1 in 10 of the 46,000 keywords he tracked had an AI overview of some kind.

As you can see, the majority of those were for informational - or TOFU - content.

If you look further down, AI overviews appear far less in transactional or even navigational searches.

As Capper said, "...for the most part…these are informational leaning, sort of already low-click SERPs."

While Capper provides an overview of his findings he does not offer advice on HOW to rank in AI Overviews.

Like many of you, Lily Ray questions all the advice on how to rank in AIO:

For all the people talking about how to rank in LLMs, especially Google’s AI Overviews, I’d love to see the evidence.

What does AI-driven search mean for SEO?

I suggest sticking with the fundamentals, so your site and content is easily understood by both users and AI systems.

  • Prioritize depth and scope in your content creation. Instead of targeting single keywords, aim to answer a wide range of related questions within a given topic.
  • Keep in mind the different search intents (informational, navigational, transactional) for targeted optimization.
  • Focus on quality over quantity in your link-building strategies. Earning backlinks from authoritative and relevant websites is more important than ever.
  • Technical SEO needs to encompass AI optimization. Websites must be structured for easy crawling and interpretation by AI systems, using schema markup and structured data to increase content understanding.

AI overviews are a relatively new feature, and their behavior and impact are likely to change.

As always; monitor and adapt.


Google doesn't care about SEO tools

A mini panic ensued last week as a number of SEO data-tracking tools stopped reporting.

While this was going on, Google told TechCrunch that it is forcing users to turn on JavaScript to use Search.

It seems this action caused the issue of non-functioning tools.

But, is there more to it?

I read about 20 articles and posts on this.

Patrick Hathaway of Sitebulb, gave the most plausible explanation for what's really going on:

I've condensed his comments, but you can read the entire post on LinkedIn.

"...is this an attack on keyword tools?

Very unlikely, in my opinion.

It is much more likely to be a reaction to a growing threat to Google's dominance - LLMs like ChatGPT becoming seen as an adequate/better replacement to Google search.

By making their data more difficult to access at scale, Google are protecting themselves against LLMs training their data sets based on Google's data.

Google do not want LLMs accessing their search results or their AI Overviews (and which queries trigger them) - that's the reason for this outage. Keyword tracking tools are just collateral damage."

My take: Google does not care about SEO tools, they care about other search and answer engines eating into their market share.

I wonder what - or who - is next?

I hope these insights help. For more tips, follow me here.

This is not an ad...

Did a friend or colleague forward this newsletter to you?

You can get a copy straight to your inbox twice a month.

You know what to do! (Hit the button now).


Information


✶ SEO is still valuable

Semrush recently surveyed ~700 of their platform users.

78% of them consider SEO 'extremely or very valuable' for their company.

What surprised me is that 62.9% of businesses saw SEO improvements in the past six months of 2024.

I did not expect this number to be so high (but the survey sample is small).

✶ AI content and Google Search quality

Chris Nelson, Senior Staff Analyst, Search Ranking at Google has updated his LinkedIn bio.

It states that he manages "a large, global team that builds ranking solutions as part of Google Search and direct the following areas team that builds ranking solutions for Google Search."

A line under this says, "Address novel content issues (e.g., detection and treatment of AI-generated content)."

Adding "detection and treatment of AI-generated content" may signal more policy or algorithm updates ahead.

Thanks to Barry Schwartz for the information.

✶SEO winners in Google Search

Lily Ray lists the SISTRIX SEO winners in Google Search and reports on the trends and gains of 2024.

Lily noted "...a shift in Google’s ranking preferences toward sites offering authentic, user-driven experiences and specialized, authoritative content."

✶ How to measure the impact of AI overviews on SEO performance

Rich Sanger's article tells you what you need to know.


Inspiration


✶ Steal attention from someone else

I've been thinking about this quote from Rand Fishkin:

"...I’d strongly consider if you can win by making more creative content, doing more creative placements, being in sources of influence your competitors have never even tried (*cough* podcasts, email newsletters, direct ad buys, YouTube channels, organic social *cough*).”

The tactics Rand suggests are relevant to any brand awareness (or other) campaigns you design.

So, if you're still creating content just to pitch journalists and crossing your fingers for backlinks, you're missing out on massive opportunities.

What's the answer?

Build content that works harder for you and your clients across every marketing channel.

Think about those big-budget 'hero campaigns' you've created.

When you put in the time and resources to create something worthwhile, why limit its reach?

Good content is good content, period.

Whether someone's scrolling through Instagram, opening an email, or walking past a billboard, the core of what grabs their attention stays pretty much the same.

Here's the thing - the actual story doesn't need to change dramatically between Digital PR, social, or email marketing.

What changes is how you package it up.

That in-depth research report you're pitching to journalists?

  • Break it down into eye-catching social posts.
  • Turn the statistics into stunning visuals.
  • Use the insights to create newsletters that get read.

When you want to impress your clients, show them how to squeeze every drop of value from your content.

  1. Walk them through how their social media team can remix your research into perfect posts for specific channels.
  2. Demonstrate how their email or newsletter specialist can use those insights to drive traffic.
  3. Get creative - maybe that data visualization would look incredible on a downtown billboard?

Start thinking about this multi-channel potential right from the ideation stage.

  • What elements could work on video?
  • Which graphics would make great LinkedIn posts?
  • Could a single section become an effective email series?

The more versatile your content is from the start, the more value you're delivering to your clients.

This multi-channel approach not only maximizes the return on investment for your clients but also strengthens the overall impact of your PR initiatives.

The best Digital PR isn't just about getting media coverage anymore.

It's about creating content that gets noticed across a variety of channels.

When you show clients how one piece of original content can power an entire marketing strategy, that's when you become invaluable to them.

What will you do differently in 2025?

P.S.

Are you thinking about developing a survey for your Digital PR clients?

You might like to see the internal checklist we use to ensure our client surveys provide news-making stats.


Dates to watch

Monthly Observances

  • Black History Month
  • American Heart Month
  • National Weddings Month
  • National Cancer Prevention Month
  • National Library Lovers Month
  • Celebration of Chocolate Month
  • National Women Inventors Month

Weekly Observances

  • February 6-11 – New York Fashion Week
  • February 7-13 – African Heritage and Health Week
  • February 9-15 – Freelance Writers Appreciation Week
  • February 14-20 – Random Acts of Kindness Week
  • February 17-23 – National Pancake Week
  • February 24-March 2 – National Eating Disorders Awareness Week

Days

  • February 1 – First Day of Black History Month
  • February 1 – National Freedom Day
  • February 1 – National Change Your Password Day
  • February 2 – Groundhog Day
  • February 2 – 67th Annual Grammy Awards
  • February 3 – Feed the Birds Day
  • February 4 – World Cancer Day
  • February 4 – Rosa Parks Day
  • February 5 – National Girls and Women in Sports Day
  • February 9 – National Pizza Day
  • February 9 – Super Bowl LIX
  • February 11 – International Day of Women and Girls in Science
  • February 11 – National Guitar Day
  • February 12 – Abraham Lincoln’s Birthday
  • February 12 – Darwin Day
  • February 13 – World Radio Day
  • February 14 – Valentine’s Day
  • February 15 – Susan B. Anthony’s Birthday
  • February 16 – NBA All-Stars
  • February 16 – Innovation Day
  • February 17 – Presidents’ Day
  • February 22 – George Washington’s Birthday
  • February 22 – National Walking Your Dog Day
  • February 28 – Ramadan starts

Keep in touch

12424 Black Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78748
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Caffeine

My team and I have been helping brands reach their SEO traffic and conversion goals through content and links for over 10 years. Recognized by industry leaders and household brands as an authority in both organic content and digital PR.

Read more from Content Caffeine
Bar chart with red bars showing how Google classifies queries into 8 types

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. You made it. You made it through the holidays and family gatherings and did your absolute best not to check your inbox, add to your to-do list, or think about your first week back at your desk. In the meantime, I've kept tabs on the latest news and trends for you. You might find a surprise or two below! See you next time,Nicole P.S. Scroll to the end and take 3 seconds to check a box in today's poll. I want to...

a pie chart showing the percentage of 5 star reviews Google has deleted

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. Have you noticed how much search news there is lately? Today, I've added a quick 'news' section below so you can catch up. I hope you're enjoying your holidays and relaxing on the couch while you read this. See you next time,Nicole P.S. I'll be back on January 9 with your first newsletter of 2025. Happy New Year! Search News Core updates We hardly had time to blink after the November Core Update before Google...

new search database showing list of people and their details

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. 23 days and 13 hours. That's how long it took the promised 2 week November Update to complete. Now, you can dig into your data to find out how you—or your clients—were impacted. I had to get ruthless with my story selection this week. You might have noticed that there's a lot going on in search, SEO, and content. I hope you enjoy what I found. See you next time,Nicole P.S. I'll be back with your last newsletter...