Content Caffeine #28: Google losing control, 80 EEAT signals, UGC gone bad, how to create reports that get read


Content Caffeine

For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs

Hi there,

You're back!

Thanks for opening my emails and following along.

Today, you'll see my thoughts and news on:

  • Google losing control
  • The perils of user-generated content
  • 80+ E.E.A.T signals
  • Creating reports that get read

Enjoy, and I'll see you next time.
Nicole

P.S. Did someone forward this letter to you? Get content and SEO insights delivered to your inbox twice a month. It takes 5 seconds.


I want to share your:

Big news, latest resource, or outstanding results.
I'd love to support you by featuring you here. It's FREE!

Smash the button
and show me what you've got.

Insights

Google Loses Control

Is Google losing control of its algorithm?

SEO expert John Doherty thinks so.

In his recent article, he suggests Google might be facing its biggest ranking crisis ever—and they can't fix it.

Here's what stands out:

1. Lack of solutions:

Google's engineers seem stumped.

Despite recognizing the problem, Google's engineers can't pinpoint why quality sites have lost traffic and rankings.

Even more concerning? They're asking publishers for help to distinguish good content from bad.

…Literally Danny hand picked us because we all create helpful and satisfying content. They just cannot get the algorithm to understand that. They are actively doing query debugging based on examples sent by our group.
—Morgan @CharlestonCraft

2. Indifference from Google:

The disconnect between Google and the publishing industry needs to be addressed to restore trust and foster a more collaborative relationship.

Website owners at the recent Creator Summit felt Google employees dismissed their concerns and offered unhelpful responses.

Another view:

Search is incredibly complex, with billions of sites, new pages every day, and hundreds of ranking factors.

It appears that Google is struggling to keep up with this complexity.

But I think there's more at play.

Google is performing a balancing act:

  • On the one hand, they need to deliver relevant search results.
  • On the other hand, their mission is to generate revenue through advertising.

If they prioritize ad revenue, this may lead to the prominence of aggregator sites over smaller, independent publishers, even if the latter offers more valuable content.

The question is: "What does this mean for the future of independent publishing and content diversity online?"

Hit reply and tell me what you think.

ICYMI: 97% of traffic lost


Quoteworthy

Speaking his mind

"It's like Google is positioning itself as the ultimate arbiter, deciding what's "worthy" based on signals it is not just judge, jury and executioner on, but also the dictator that wrote the laws they themselves routinely flaunt…Google will lie to you and say they want "unique" voices, but they baked consensus and HCU into the algo because they want uniform."

Charles Floate @Charles_SEO

A desperate plea from the independent web

"Dear John Mu and Danny Sullivan, I have to do a shot of Tequilla (sic) every time you say, “Just make good content,” so please stop; I am begging you… Please provide real information and help the website owners you are destroying. I know you want to, as you are both amazing people."

Ben Fox, Founder, Shepherd


User-generated content goes bad

Over in London, England, the locals are deliberately giving false restaurant recommendations to keep their favorite spots tourist-free.

While that might seem harmless or even amusing, it points to a bigger issue.

When we rely too heavily on what random people post online, we're basically playing a digital lottery.

It's harder to separate truth from fiction.

Think about it - people post misleading info for all sorts of reasons: to protect their favorite local spots, to mess with AI, with malicious intent, or just for laughs.

When big tech companies—like the Google AIO/Reddit combo—vacuum up all this content to train their AI or power their search results, those 'white lies' and deliberate misdirections can snowball into something bigger.

What to do?

  • Monitor online conversations and reviews: Brands need to stay vigilant about what is said about them online. Early detection of misleading trends or negative sentiment means you can intervene faster.
  • Engage with the community: Participate in online conversations about the brand. Respond to reviews, answer questions, and address concerns directly. When you make genuine connections, you will build trust and counter misinformation.
  • Promote trustworthy content: Encourage satisfied customers/users to share their positive experiences. User-generated content from trustworthy sources helps drown out misleading information and presents a more accurate view of the brand.
"AI Overviews are built to only show information that is backed up by top web results." The design is based on the false assumption that Google's page-ranking algorithm favors accurate results and not SEO-gamed garbage."
Benj Edwards


Story Source: Annoyed Redditors tanking Google Search results illustrates perils of AI scrapers

I hope these insights help. For more tips, follow me here.

This is not an ad...

Did a friend or colleague forward this newsletter to you?

You can get a copy straight to your inbox twice a month.

You know what to do! (Hit the button now).


Information

✶ November 2024 Update Rolling Out

We were warned and now it's here.

On Monday, Google began rolling out a new search ranking update.

Google stated on LinkedIn:

This update is designed to continue our work to improve the quality of our search results by showing more content that people find genuinely useful and less content that feels like it was made just to perform well on Search.

Their announcement on X generated a flood of comments which leave no doubt as to how SEOs and publishers feel.


✶ How Google evaluates E-E-A-T: 80+ signals

Back in 2022, Olaf Kopp wrote a widely-read article for Search Engine Land about E-E-A-T signals.

Last week, he published a roundup of 80+ E-E-A-T signals he's identified from his research.

In case you didn't know, his research on patents and papers relating to SEO is intense and extensive.

Kopp currently lists 212 items in his free searchable database.


✶ Goodbye HARO

HARO, Help a Reporter Out, which became Connectively, will shut down on December 9th.

It appears that CisionOne is wrapping journalist outreach tools (Connectively) into its platform for media monitoring and analytics.

There are alternatives.

You can try SourcesofSources which was created by by the original founder of HARO. JournoFinder and Qwoted are other popular choices.


Inspiration

✶ Create reports that get read

Client reports aren't always compelling reads.

As SEOs and marketers, we spend a decent amount of time preparing reports for clients—and it's not always fun.

Like me, you might wonder how much of your hard work gets noticed or read.

You know I'm a fan of storytelling, and great reporting means telling stories.

But you need balance.

In PR—or any agency—reporting, there's a fine line between engaging stories and professional business communication.

While narrative elements will strengthen your reports, they shouldn't overshadow what matters most to clients: Results and ROI.

The key is to think like a journalist rather than a data analyst.

Instead of just listing metrics and achievements, weave them into a story that shows the brand's results and impact.

Here's how to strike a balance:

Focus on key campaigns

Instead of trying to tell a story for every single metric or campaign, concentrate on a few key initiatives that had significant outcomes.

For example, if a particular digital PR campaign led to a notable increase in brand mentions or website traffic, use that as your focal point.

Let KPIs drive the narrative

Every story element in your report should connect directly to your key performance indicators (KPIs).

Instead of writing, "We launched an exciting social media campaign," frame it as "Our targeted LinkedIn campaign drove 150% more engagement than previous quarters, resulting in 45 qualified leads for your sales team."

The goal isn't to tell just any story – it's to tell the story your data is revealing.

When you spot a trend in your metrics, use that as your narrative hook.

Did website traffic spike after a particular media placement?

That's not just a number; it's the beginning of a cause-and-effect story that demonstrates clear business value.

Data: Your central character

While storytelling adds color to your reports, data is your primary narrative thread.

Think of metrics as chapters that move your story forward.

Instead of saving all your numbers for a couple of pages of charts and graphics, include them naturally throughout your report.

Example:

"The campaign gained momentum in March, with social shares increasing 40% week-over-week. By April, this heightened visibility translated into 12 inbound media requests – triple our monthly average."

Keep anecdotes focused

Client anecdotes and examples can bring your results to life, but keep them brief and relevant.

A two-sentence example that illustrates a successful media placement is helpful. A 3 paragraph story about your pitching process probably isn't.

Good example: "Our targeted strategy paid off when The Atlantic's senior editor responded within 24 hours, leading to coverage that drove 25,000 visitors to your website."

Professional language sets the tone

Avoid marketing buzzwords, excessive adjectives, or a casual tone. Your goal is to sound like a trusted business partner, not a creative storyteller.

Instead of: "We absolutely crushed the competition with an amazing campaign that got tons of awesome feedback!"

Try: "The campaign exceeded key metrics across all channels, securing 15 tier-one placements and increasing share of voice by 25%."

Connect everything back to business impact

When highlighting a successful social media post, don't just celebrate the engagement numbers—connect them to broader business goals.

Example:

"The LinkedIn thought leadership piece generated 1,493 interactions, including comments from 9 C-suite executives at target accounts. This visibility supported your Q3 enterprise sales initiatives, with sales reporting that two of these accounts entered the pipeline."

Remember, your clients aren't looking for a gripping tale–they're looking for evidence that their investment is paying off.

Use storytelling techniques to make that evidence clearer and more memorable, but always keep the business impact front and center.

When you strike this balance, you'll create persuasive and informative reports your clients actually read.

Do these tips help you?

Related: 8 PR Report Examples & Templates to Bookmark for Inspiration


Keep in touch

12424 Black Hills Drive, Austin, TX 78748
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Caffeine

My team and I have been helping brands reach their SEO traffic and conversion goals through content and links for over 10 years. Recognized by industry leaders and household brands as an authority in both organic content and digital PR.

Read more from Content Caffeine
graphic from semrush showing survey response on site performance in the past 6 months.

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. It's been a wild couple of weeks - in business and life! How are you doing? If you've had trouble keeping up with what's happening in SEO, search, and marketing, I've got you covered. As always, I hope you find value in my original insights and tips. Read on... See you next time,Nicole P.S. Want to steal attention from your competitors? Check out today's 'Inspiration' section. P.P.S. I've added back the 'Dates to...

Bar chart with red bars showing how Google classifies queries into 8 types

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. You made it. You made it through the holidays and family gatherings and did your absolute best not to check your inbox, add to your to-do list, or think about your first week back at your desk. In the meantime, I've kept tabs on the latest news and trends for you. You might find a surprise or two below! See you next time,Nicole P.S. Scroll to the end and take 3 seconds to check a box in today's poll. I want to...

a pie chart showing the percentage of 5 star reviews Google has deleted

Content Caffeine For content-obsessed marketers and SEOs Hi there, Welcome back. Have you noticed how much search news there is lately? Today, I've added a quick 'news' section below so you can catch up. I hope you're enjoying your holidays and relaxing on the couch while you read this. See you next time,Nicole P.S. I'll be back on January 9 with your first newsletter of 2025. Happy New Year! Search News Core updates We hardly had time to blink after the November Core Update before Google...